Best Old Fashioned Ice Cream Makers in 2021

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. We will receive a small commission at no additional cost to you and be incredibly grateful.

Old Fashioned Ice Cream MakersWe often tend to forget that before the arrival of electric ice cream makers, the very first models were manual. Let’s find out best old fashioned ice cream maker.

Many do not know about the old fashioned ice cream maker, especially since they have become sporadic. It is easier to find them in flea markets or collectors. The old fashioned ice cream maker is still favored by many experts due to its unique features.

What could be better than turning to vintage to make an excellent old creamy and delicious ice cream by the best old fashioned ice cream maker? Let us present them to you in the simplest way possible.

Top 5 Best Old Fashioned Ice Cream Makers

#1 Elite Gourmet EIM-924L Old Fashioned Electric Maker Machine

The Elite Gourmet EIM-924L Old Fashioned Ice Cream Maker rockets on top of the list by its unique and outstanding features. Notably, it has a unique look of a hand-crafted wood bucket which is well-sculptured as a pineapple shape.

The machine features a mighty motor and an extra-large capacity. It can process up to four quarts of ice cream each team. It can be used as a heavy-duty canister to store many types of cold desserts such as ice cream, gelato, yogurt, and sorbet.

If you are having a family union party or birthday barbeques with more than 10 participants, this EIM-924L model is the best old fashioned ice cream maker that we can offer.

Pros

  • Unique wood pine bucket design
  • Powerful performance and high efficiency
  • Can process many types of cold dessert
  • Large capacity

Cons

  • The product is not made of wood
  • The bowl cannot be put in the freezer for more than 48 hours, which will cause crack and damage

 

#2 AMERIHOME ICM6C Old Fashioned Ice Cream Maker

Most customers praise the AMERIHOME ICM6B Old Fashioned Ice Cream Maker is one of the most valued items that they had ever purchased. This ice cream maker has a 2-in-1 feature of interchanging between electric to manual operation.

So, it is an excellent combination of modern and traditional ice cream maker. For the electric motor, it is heavy-duty and efficient, which can handle most types of ingredients and stiff batch. The overall design has a stylish retro bucket type.

Notably, many purchases are happy with the fact that their ice cream maker is covered by original wooden material, unlike other bad-quality products. It will be an excellent gift for any ice cream lover from walks of life.

Pros

  • Great combination between traditional and modern style
  • High efficiency and strong motor
  • Covered by real wood
  • Can handle up to 6 quarts of ice cream in only 30 minutes

Cons

  • Hard to use with complicated operation
  • Cause ice cream leaking after long using time

 

#3 Oster 4-Quart Wood Bucket Ice Cream Maker

At first glance, the Oster Wood Bucket Ice Cream Maker is an entirely manual ice cream machine. However, it runs entirely by electricity. With this unit, you can enjoy a look of a traditional ice cream maker without using much effort to operate.

It also features an extra-large capacity of four quarts, which is sufficient for a standard family of up to six members. The consistency of quality and operating system is extremely high and is favorited by many ice cream lovers.

Pros

  • Traditional bucket design with a powerful motor
  • Runs by electricity
  • Easy to use and operate
  • Extra-large capacity
  • High-quality ice cream outputs

Cons

  • Cannot make ice cream manually

 

#4 Nostalgia Electric Bucket Ice Cream Maker

If you want to have an old fashioned ice cream maker with high efficiency and robust performance through the years, the Nostalgia Electric Bucket Ice Cream Maker is ideal. With a massive capacity of one gallon, the unit is perfect for any parties and gatherings.

Indeed, the machine features a nostalgic look with full-wooden cover with red cedar-wood color. It can be a great decorative item for any modern kitchen. And behind that outstanding look is innovative technology-appliances.

Its durable and reliable electric motor runs smoothly and effortlessly, which causes no overheat issue or sudden shutdown. The operating system is user-friendly and straightforward. Remember to add salt and ice before turning on ice cream making mode.

A massive number of users report that the ice cream texture made by Nostalgia machine is smooth and creamy with delicious taste. Every customer loves how it is easy to assemble, operate, and clean.

Lastly, with an affordable price and clear instruction manual, it is a must-have old fashioned ice cream maker for any household.

Pros

  • Superb efficiency and stable performance
  • Traditional wooden design with eye-catching color
  • Powerful motor for effortless operating
  • Trouble-free machine

Cons

  • Causes freezing problem frequently
  • The plastic paddle is too small

 

#5 Aroma Housewares 4-Quart Traditional Ice Cream Maker

The Aroma Housewares Ice Cream Maker comes with two times the cooling technology of conventional models for fast, deeper temperature. It ensures the quality of ice cream without being melt and watery.

The product is appreciated for saving energy, keeping cold heat longer than preserving ice cream effectively. Its ergonomic design with the ability to put ice cream into the tube even when the machine is in operation is a unique selling point.

Moreover, the product features a compact design. It is easy to use and can observe the machine works with the semi-opened lid.

The machine uses a simple operating system, easy to manipulate adjusting ice cream mode conveniently. Generally, the ice cream maker meets the needs of small families with many color choices.

Pros

  • Advanced technology appliances of energy-saving and cooling features
  • Ergonomic design with an eye-catching look
  • Easy to use and compact

Cons

  • Only suitable for families with less than five members
  • Low durability

 

How to Choose the Best Old Fashioned Ice Cream Maker?

To choose your Caribbean ice cream maker correctly, you must highlight specific selection criteria.

Utilization Facility

Many people have been disgusted by the ice cream maker. They followed the instructions, but instead of a creamy sorbet, they had a kind of substance with pieces of ice!

Ease of use is crucial to the success of your ice cream. Even if it is expensive, the ice turbine is the most suitable. It often has a control panel to adjust the temperature, the preparation time, etc.

You should not buy an electric ice cream maker to realize that the result does not meet your expectations. And you buy an ice turbine afterward. Even if you are a purist and want the manual ice cream maker, choose the variants with a motor.

Length of the Crank Arm

Traditional ice cream makers do not all have the same length of crank arms. Some have long ones, like shorter ones.

It strongly influences the practicality of the machine.

Capacity

The capacity of your ice cream maker will determine the number of servings or liters you can make. The average size ranges from 2 to 4 liters. Compressor ice cream makers can prepare much more.

The portions are misleading. If a mechanic tells you that it can make ten proportions, then keep in mind that it will be minimum portions. Manual models can create liters of sorbet. Be careful, do not be tempted to buy a 5-liter ice cream maker and tell yourself that you will be quiet.

The higher the quantity, the longer the sorbet will take. You could tell yourself that it does not matter because you will only prepare 2 liters at a time. But the price difference between a two and 5-litre model is considerable.

So, depending on the size of your family, choose the ice cream maker accordingly.

Material

There are manual ice cream makers made of wood, copper, or aluminum.

Noise Pollution

Any device with a motor will make noise. And in this category, the ice turbine is the big loser. It has a considerable nuisance since it turns and refrigerated at the same time. The electric ice cream maker is also noisy, but less than a vacuum cleaner, for example.

It is not necessarily the primary criterion for choosing an ice cream maker, but it is something that one must keep in mind.

FAQ

How does an old fashioned ice cream maker work?

The manual ice cream maker, also called traditional ice cream maker, hand-cranked ice cream maker, old fashioned ice cream maker or West Indian ice cream maker is the most past model of ice cream maker in the world.

It comes in the form of a large tank that contains a smaller stainless-steel tank. It is in the latter that the preparation takes place which has been previously placed in a freezer for an average of seven hours.

Later it will become ice (in the large plastic container). It is then a question of turning with a constant frequency until the mixture solidifies. As soon as this stage (which lasts about 15 minutes) comes to an end, you can immediately consume your homemade ice cream in the old way.

The principle is hardly different from an electric ice cream maker, the blades being replaced by an arm or end of which is a crank.

Why choose a manual ice cream maker?

The reasons for choosing a manual ice cream maker are also diverse and varied:

  • For the sake of maintaining certain traditions, mainly in the West Indies;
  • Out of nostalgia for the good old days;
  • Because they don’t consume current;
  • They are ecological.

Where to get an old fashioned ice cream maker?

It is at this level that things are complicated. As mentioned above, this type of crank has become very rare. It is easier to find them in garage sales, flea markets or in auctions with collectors.

 

Conclusion

For the criteria, you have to look at the capacity, the ease of use and the accessories provided. Choosing an old fashioned ice cream maker is often tricky.

But you could say that it’s worth it when you see the expression of satisfaction on the face of one of your guests when the creamy texture melts in their mouth. We hope this article helps you with choosing the best old fashioned ice cream maker.

AFFILIATE DISCLOSURE

Hiltonheadicecreamshop.com is a participant in the Amazon.com Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to amazon.com, amazon.co.uk, amazon.ca and any other website that may be affiliated with Amazon.com Service LLC Associates Program.