Best Nostalgia Ice Cream Maker Reviews in 2022

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. We will receive a small commission at no additional cost to you and be incredibly grateful.

Among thousands of ice cream makers on the market, Nostalgia is always on top of the best-seller. Here, we have reviews of Nostalgia Ice Cream Maker.

Summer is coming, and nothing is sweeter than an ice cream which you made by yourself. Recently, there are so many ice cream makers that allow you to make ice cream at home. And you can always find some new recipes on the internet.

The ice cream makers will bring you and your family excellent expNostalgia Ice Cream Makererience while making your frozen treat! And among so many brands, I believe that Nostalgia is the best brand for you to try. In this article, I will give you Nostalgia Ice Cream Maker reviews with the most up-to-date information.

Nostalgia Ice Cream Maker Reviews

Nostalgia is a very famous brand in the US which provide so many helpful tools for making ice cream, hot dog, cotton candy, chocolate, and more. Their products are good-looking and very easy to use. About the ice cream maker, Nostalgia has four ice cream makers bellow:


Nostalgia ICMP600WD Electric Bucket Ice Cream Maker

If you are looking for an ice cream maker for your friends and family, I think you should choose the Nostalgia ICMP600WD Electric Bucket Ice Cream Maker. This machine allows you to create 6-quarts of ice cream in a few minutes. It comes with a very vintage design, and you can also make gelato and frozen yogurt.

Also, the product comes with Nostalgia Ice cream kits that can offer you so many flavor mixtures, including vanilla, chocolate, strawberry, and no-sugar vanilla. The bucket is wooden and very easy to clean. And the lid is glass so you can see the ice cream inside. You will find it is beneficial when freezing storage.

Moreover, Nostalgia ICMP600WD has a potent motor with a motor lock to keep the machine in place and secure all other parts when making ice cream. For me, it is fantastic to have a plastic liner inside the freezer because it can prevent leaking and is very easy to clean.


  • Lightweight and easy to move
  • Big size for more productive
  • Easy to use and clean
  • High-quality bucket
  • Very quiet and take a short time to make ice cream


  • Vulnerable dasher


Nostalgia DIC4AQ Deluxe Ice Cream Maker

The Nostalgia DIC4AQ ice cream maker is smaller than the product above. It can produce four quarts of ice cream within about twenty minutes. Like other products from Nostalgia, you can use DIC4AQ to make ice cream, frozen yogurt, sorbet, and even gelato. It is a lovely machine for everyday use.

Unlike ICMP600WD, DIC4AQ comes with aqua design; it looks straightforward and more suitable for modern kitchen with the contemporary outlook. What we like most about this product are the dual-insulated walls that can keep ice and salt cold when it churns the ingredients. This feature helps to create the best flavor for your ice cream.

Also, this machine is straightforward to control. You can easily use it with the on/off push button. And the upper of the bucket is accessible so you can quickly fill salt and ice. Meanwhile, the separate chute allows you to add your favorite topping in a few seconds.

The durable bottom-drive motor of this machine will ensure the sustainable churning process to make the best ice cream for your family.


  • Easy to use and children-friendly design
  • Remain great flavor for ice cream
  • Allow creative ingredients
  • It takes a short time to make ice cream


  • It can be slippery when churning
  • Don’t have a cover cap for add-on area


Nostalgia CICM 2WB Electric Ice Cream Maker Crusher Makes

If you are looking for a mini-size ice cream maker for your small family, we think that the Nostalgia CICM2WWB Electric Ice Cream maker is the best choice for you.

With this machine, you can add whatever you want, including chocolate chips, nuts, and even candy bars to make the best ice cream for your family. Besides, it comes with a meager price for the quality.

The Canister and Dasher are the two features that make this ice cream maker so unique. They are an excellent combination that can give you a smooth and creamy output. Moreover, the durable bottom-drive electric motor is also a big plus. You can forget about the churning problem!

Also, the bucket of this ice cream maker is detachable. It is beneficial to maintain a cold temperature when ready to serve. Like other ice cream maker from Nostalgia, this version has a top lid which allows you to add ice and salt in your ingredients easily. The hand crank candy crusher will help if you want to add candy in your ice cream.


  • Easy to use and control
  • User-friendly design
  • Perfect for adding hard ingredients like candy
  • Reasonable price
  • Smooth and creamy output


  • Small capacity


Nostalgia PICM4BG Electric Ice Cream Maker

And the last ice cream maker I want to show you today is Nostalgia PICM4BG Electric ice cream maker. Like the wooden version that I reviewed in the first part, this machine comes with an easy-carry handle to quickly move it around.

Besides, the device is not for making ice cream only; you can use it to make gelato and frozen yogurt. It is very convenient feature that many customers love.

This ice cream maker is four-quarts capacity – the most popular size on the market recently. And it has so many benefits for the user. The cleaning process, for example, is a big plus! With a plastic bucket, you can wipe and clean dirt in a few minutes. Besides, it has a see-thru lid, which allows you to observe the ice cream making process.

Last but not least, this ice cream maker has a powerful electric motor which is in charge of all churning process. As a result, you don’t need to try hard to mix the ingredients. Besides, the motor lock will make sure that the machine can’t move around while making ice cream. The device also comes with some delicious recipes that you can consider.


  • Powerful and durable motor
  • Explicit instruction and helpful recipes
  • Solid construction and convenient


  • Thin aluminum inner bowl
  • The handle is not corrosion-resistant


What to Consider When Looking for an Ice Cream Maker?

Freezing Style

The freezing style will decide if your ice cream is delicious or not. And there are some popular freezing styles that you can consider:

Cooling with ice and salt: this style is the classic style, but it works pretty well

Compressor models: it allows you to churn batch, but it is costly

Freezer bowl: it is just acceptable but not very convenient because you need to freeze the ingredients for some time before churning the ice cream.

So, each style will have both pros and cons. And what you need to do is understanding your requirements and choose the most suitable one for you.


A powerful motor is the must-have features if you are looking for a good ice cream maker. It will take you at least 20 minutes to churn ice cream, so I recommend that you choose electric machines to save time and effort.

However, for many people, hand-churning with a manual machine is a good idea to memorize the past. The hand-churning device makes it very convenient for you to bring it to your family’s picnic and try making some ice cream at the park.


And the next essential feature is capacity. So, how many members are there in your family? How many people will join your party? If you want to make ice cream for more than eight people or to serve a party, you should choose the Nostalgia ICMP600WD because it is big enough for you to help many people at one-time making.

However, if you want to make ice cream for a regular family gathering, Nostalgia PICM4BG and Nostalgia DIC4AQ are the two options that you can consider. It is not too big but not too small for your family. And if you need to make ice cream for less than four people, CICM 2WW is the best choice.


Final Words

So, above is my Nostalgia Ice Cream Maker Reviews. I believe that with the information in this article, you can decide the best product for you. As you may know, ice cream is not for making ice cream only. Instead, you can use it to make frozen yogurt and sorbet. And you will be surprised by its outcome!

With the Nostalgia ice cream maker, you can make the best ice cream for your family and create a fantastic party for your children. Let’s try to make your ice cream with your family. And don’t forget to leave a comment to share your experience with us.

AFFILIATE DISCLOSURE is a participant in the Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to,, and any other website that may be affiliated with Service LLC Associates Program.